top of page
  • Naomi Stephens | Permaculture Designer

Comparing the Benefits: Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil vs Basic Potting Soil for Tomatoes

Choosing suitable soil for planting tomatoes is a foundational step that directly influences plant health, growth rates, and yield. The soil acts as a physical support structure for tomato plants and a vital reservoir of nutrients, water, and air essential for optimal growth.

Given the demanding nature of tomato plants and the importance of organic gardening, selecting between high-quality Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil and enriched potting becomes a critical decision for gardeners aiming to maximize their harvest while maintaining plant health.

Now, let's explore our gardening dilemma: selecting between Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil and potting soils. This choice extends beyond merely picking a bag of soil; it's about deciding on the soil mixture that will act as the foundation for your tomato plant's future, guaranteeing a successful blend of nutrients and support for vigorous growth.

On one side, we have Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil, specifically designed to cater to the comprehensive demands of raised bed gardening and those nutrient-seeking tomatoes. This option includes a blend of organic materials and mulch, poised to nourish your plants from the seedling stage to harvest, ensuring they receive all the necessary nutrients.

Conversely, bare potting soil is often more affordable and a go-to for gardeners worldwide. This general-purpose solution can support a wide range of plants, including tomatoes.

Each has its champions and critics, and both have merits that deserve a closer look. By exploring the pros and cons of each, we aim to empower you, the gardener, with the knowledge to make the best choice for your tomato paradise.

Decoding What Tomatoes Crave in Soil - Best soil mix for tomatoes in raised beds

Tomatoes are the prima donnas of the garden, demanding particular conditions for their soil environment, particularly a need for soil rich in organic matter.

Organic matter

Organic matter acts as the secret sauce. It helps soil retain moisture and drain well, preventing waterlogged roots. This also highlights the importance of incorporating organic nutrients and organic fertilizer to enrich the soil, ensuring it has the perfect balance for growing healthy tomatoes.


Tomatoes are looking for a "just right" "H level, "between 6.2 and 6.8, which allows them to absorb nutrients efficiently. Too acidic or too alkaline, and your tomatoes might as well be trying to dine with a closed mouth—nutrients just can't be properly absorbed. If you are unsure of your pH, you can easily purchase a pH tester kit to find out.

Soil Structure

We can't overlook the importance of soil structure for the plant's roots. Plants thrive in the best loose and crumbly soil, perfect for fostering excellent root growth and enabling roots to access water, oxygen, and nutrients easily.

This optimal soil structure, ideal for even heirloom tomatoes, is often characterized as a well-draining, sandy loam—the soil that holds moisture without becoming waterlogged.


Regarding nutrients, tomatoes are heavy feeders requiring a balanced diet of nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and various micronutrients for swift growth and fruitful production. Enriching the soil with composted materials, like composted cow manure or mushroom compost, and adding supplements such as fish emulsion and alfalfa meal can significantly boost your tomato plants' health.

Keeping these soil requirements in mind is not just about giving your tomatoes what they want; it's about setting the stage for vibrant growth, health, and the promise of those juicy, ripe tomatoes we all crave.

The Magic Behind Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil for Tomato Plants

Crafted with love and science, Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil is the superhero soil explicitly designed for the unique needs of raised garden beds and those voracious tomato plants we adore.

When it comes to providing the perfect soil environment for Roma tomatoes, Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil has much going for it. Its specially formulated mixture of organic materials, including sphagnum peat moss and aged compost, is designed to provide all the necessary nutrients and conditions for optimal plant growth.

Why is this soil a game changer? It's jam-packed with organic materials, providing an all-you-can-eat buffet of nutrients for your plants from when they sprout to harvest. This specially formulated mix perfectly balances drainage and water retention, ensuring your tomato roots are hydrated but never soggy. Plus, because it's all organized, you can rest easy knowing your garden is eco-friendly and your tomatoes grow in the best possible environment.

Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil enhances soil structure, creating an ideal home for plants where roots can spread out, breathe, and absorb nutrients efficiently. In other words, it makes the perfect backdrop for robust growth and bountiful harvests.

The Essentials of Basic Potting Soil

Now, let's shift to the unsung hero of the gardening world: Basic Potting Soil! This trusty blend is the backbone for countless gardens, offering a solid, reliable foundation that caters to a wide array of plants, including our beloved tomatoes. Bare Potting Soil is like the all-rounder friend who's always who's for you: versatile and dependable; it's an ideal choice for both newbie gardeners and seasoned green thumbs alike.

What sets Basic Potting Soil apart? Its straightforward, no-frills composition, enriched with organic material, provides a balanced environment for plant growth. This soil, infused with organic material, is designed to support your plants' needs with decent drainage and a moderate moisture retention level. While it might not have the bells and whistles of specialized mixes, Basic Potting Soil brings a lot to the table with its affordability and general suitability for various gardening projects.

By choosing Basic Potting Soil, you're opting for a practical solution that gets the job done, including the benefits of organic material. Thanks to the inclusion of organic material, it welcomes your tomato plants with open arms, supporting their growth without overshadowing their needs.

The Lowdown on Soil Choices: Pros and Cons Breakdown

Alright, gardeners, it's time to dig a little deeper into our soil saga and break down the advantages and drawbacks of each soil type. This way, you can decide which soil will be your partner in the quest for gardening glory!

Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil: Pros and Cons


  • Tailor-made for Success: This soil is specifically formulated for raised beds and hungry tomato plants, ensuring your garden is off to a fantastic start.

  • Nutrient-Rich Buffet: Packed with organic materials, this buffet is like a gift set meal for your plants, providing all the nutrients they need from seedlings to fruit.

  • Optimal Water Balance: Designed for perfect drainage and water retention, preventing waterlogged roots and keeping your tomatoes happy and hydrated.

  • Eco-Friendly Choice: Organic ingredients make it a better fit for the environment, making your garden a green oasis in more ways than one.



  • Price Point: Quality comes at a cost, making this soil a pricier option than essential mixes.

  • Specific Use: While perfect for raised beds, its specialized mix may not be as versatile for all garden projects.

Bare Potting Soil: Pros and Cons


  • Jack of All Trades: Versatile and dependable, this soil is a great all-rounder for various plants, not just tomatoes.

  • Budget-Friendly: More affordable than specialized soils, it's solid for gardeners watching their wallet.

  • Availability: It can be easily found in most garden centers and stores, making it a convenient option for impromptu gardening projects.



  • Nutrient Levels: Might lack the rich nutrient mix of specialized soils, requiring additional supplements for heavy feeders like tomatoes.

  • Water Management: Offers decent drainage and moisture retention but may not always hit the sweet spot needed for

Cost Comparison - Price Breakdown:

Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil might initially make your wallet a bit lighter, with its premium price tag reflecting its specialized composition and organic credentials. This investment, however, can translate to savings down the road. Thanks to its nutrient-packed nature, you may spend less on fertilizers and plant health boosters. The soil's efficiency encouraging vigorous plant growth and higher yields could mean more tomatoes per plant, potentially lowering the initial cost per tomato!

On the other hand, Basic Potting Soil charms with its affordability and ease of availability. If your budget is tight, it's a fantasist's starting point. Remember, though, that you might need to invest in extra nutrients and perhaps more soil amendments over time to meet the specific demands of your tomatoes, which could narrow the initial cost gap.

Cost-Effectiveness Over Time:

Evaluating cost-effectiveness isn't just about assessing upfront expenses; it's about looking at the bigger picture. Organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil, with its long-term benefits on soil health and plant productivity, might offer better value over several growing seasons. Its organic matter content can improve your garden's soil and fertility in the long run, possibly reducing the need for future soil purchases.

While basic potting soil is better economically initially, maintaining a healthy and productive garden may require ongoing soil amendments and investment in fertilizers. Depending on your gardening practices and how well you manage soil health, this could ultimately affect its cost-effectiveness.

In summary, consider the initial price tag and potential long-term benefits and costs when choosing between these two soil types. Your decision could influence not just this season's harvest but also the sustainability and productivity of your garden in the years to come. 🌻

Other tips for success

Soil test - Know What Your Soil Needs

Now that we've discussed the different types of soil available let's discuss how to ensure your plants get what they need from it. A soil test is a simple and effective way to assess the nutrient levels in your garden. It helps determine which nutrients are lacking and guides your fertilizer choices.

You can purchase a soil test kit from your local garden center or send a soil sample to a lab for more comprehensive results. Once you have the results, you can make informed decisions about which nutrients to add and in what quantities, ensuring your tomatoes have everything they need for successful growth.

Watering Tips - Don't Drown Your Tomatoes!

While water is essential for plant growth, too much can harm your tomato plants. Overwatering can lead to root rot and other diseases, stunting their growth and reducing fruit production. On the other hand, under-watering can cause stress and nutrient deficiencies in your plants.

To ensure proper watering for your tomatoes, check the soil moisture levels regularly by sticking your finger into the soil about an inch or two. If the soil feels dry, it's time to do it. When watering, aim for the base of the plant rather than overhead to avoid wetting the leaves and increasing the risk of disease.

You may need to water your tomatoes daily in hotter months, but in cooler weather, once or twice a week may be sufficient. Consistency is critical, so try to water your plants simultaneously each day.

Sun and Shade - Finding the Perfect Balance

Tomato plants love sunlight; it helps them produce sugars for energy and ripen their fruit. But too much sun can also be harmful, causing heat stress and sunscald on delicate leaves and fruits. On the other hand, insufficient sun can result in spindly, weak plants with low fruit production.

Aim for at least 6-8 hours of sunlight per day for your tomato plants to strike the perfect balance. If your garden is prone to harsh midday sun, consider providing shade with a thin fabric or mesh cover. You can also grow taller plants nearby, offering natural shade for your tomato plants.

Remember to rotate your plants yearly to prevent them from being in the same spot and receiving the same amount of sunlight each growing season. This will help ensure a healthy and productive garden year after year.

Fighting insects - Prevention is Key.

One common challenge for tomato growers is pest control, as pests and insects can damage or even kill your plants. To prevent these pesky critters from wreaking havoc in your garden, it's best to take a proactive approach. Beneficial insects, such as ladybugs and praying mantis, feed on common tomato pests like aphids and mites. Additionally, practicing good garden hygiene by clearing debris and weeds can reduce potential hiding places for insects.

Start by regularly inspecting your plants for any signs of insect infestation, such as holes in leaves or chewed fruits. If you spot any, remove the affected leaves or fruits immediately to prevent further spread. It's also worth visiting your local nursery for advice on pest control solutions and to check if the issue might be related to contaminated soil, which can exacerbate pest problems.

Finally, consider using natural pest control methods like neem oil or insecticidal soap, which are gentler on the environment and safe for consumption. And remember, healthy plants are more resistant to pests and diseases, so keeping your plants well-fed and watered can also help prevent pest infestations.

Considering garden soil or native soil

Another essential factor to consider when growing tomatoes is the type of soil present in your garden. If you're using your resting garden bed, it's necessary to assess the quality of your native soil and whether it will be suitable for growing healthy tomatoes.

If your native soil is heavy and clay-like, it can impede water drainage and lead to root rot. In this case, amending the soil with organic matter like compost or using a raised bed filled with quality growing mix might be a better option. On the other hand, if your native soil is sandy and low in nutrients, adding amendments such as peat moss and fertilizer can improve its fertility.

Consider conducting a soil test to determine the pH level and nutrient content of your native soil, which


In the verdant world of gardening, the soil you choose acts as the foundation of your garden's success. Whether you gravitate towards the nutrient-rich, organic Raised Bed Miracle Grow Soil or opt for versatile, budget-friendly Basic Potting Soil, each offers benefits for different gardening styles and objectives.

The key is to assess your garden's specifications, budgetary constraints, and long-term aspirations. Remember, gardening is not just about the immediate gratification of seeing your plants grow; it's about nurturing a tiny seed into a thriving plant that bears delicious fruits. By making an informed soil selection, you're setting the stage for a garden that's sustainable, fruitful, and rewarding.


Q: Can I mix different types of soil?

Yes, you can mix different types of soil to create a customized blend that meets your garden's specific needs. Just be sure to consider each soil's characteristics and adjust accordingly.

Q: How often should I fertilize my tomatoes?

It depends on the fertilizer you are using and the nutrient levels in your soil. It's best to Refer to the manufacturer for specific guidelines, and it's always an idea to do a soil test first to determine which nutrients your plants may need. Over-fertilizing can be harmful, so it's essential to find a balance.

Q: Can I reuse my potting soil?

Yes, you can reuse potting soil from previous seasons, but mix it with fresh soil and amend it with organic matter or fertilizer to replenish any nutrients that may have been depleted. Before reusing the potting soil, it's also an idea to do a soil test to check the nutrient levels.

Q: How often should I water my tomato plants?

Tomato plants typically need 1-2 inches of water per week, but this can vary depending on weather conditions and the type of soil you use.

Check the moisture levels in the soil before watering, and aim for consistency in your watering routine. Daily watering may be necessary in hotter months, while once or twice a week may suffice in more excellent weather conditions. Remember to water at the base of the plant rather than overhead to avoid wetting the leaves.

As always, it's essential to monitor your plants and adjust watering as needed. If you found this useful please subscribe for more!



Get free resources, useful, well researched new ideas. Subscribe.

Subscribe for free Permaculture resources periodically. 

Subscribe for more relevant information on small space gardening and Urban permaculture. Be the first to see exclusive and new content. Be updated on the latest on what's going on in the urban gardening world.

See More

bottom of page